A second problem with the Court's examples is that they illustrate wanton, but nevertheless intentional, killings, rather than unintentional killings. . A scant four years later, however, the Court validated Georgia's new machinery, and in 1977 executions resumed. 1759, 64 L.Ed.2d 398 (1980). Distinguishing intentional from reckless action in assessing culpability is particularly important in felony-murder cases. See Cabana v. Bullock, 474 U.S., at 397-407, 106 S.Ct., at 702-708 (BLACKMUN, J., dissenting); id., at 407-408, 106 S.Ct., at 708-709 (STEVENS, J., dissenting). The Arizona Supreme Court wrote: "Intend [sic ] to kill includes the situation in which the defendant intended, contemplated, or anticipated that lethal force would or might be used or that life would or might be taken in accomplishing the underlying felony." But the fact that this Court's death penalty jurisprudence can validate different results in analytically indistinguishable cases suggests that something more profoundly disturbing than faithlessness to precedent is at work in capital sentencing. If they'd executed him for his crime the first time, those people might still be alive today.". "Give us some water just leave us here and you all go home". Godfrey v. Georgia, 446 U.S. 420, 100 S.Ct. 15A-2000(f)(4) (1983). of Mar. Rawlinson died in 1997. And I feel bad about it happening. hcg wert viel zu niedrig; flohmarkt kilegg 2021. fhrerschein in tschechien trotz mpu; kartoffeltaschen mit schinken und kse They were convicted of felony murder in 1979 and sentenced to death. Otherwise, the court noted, Ricky Tison's participation was substantially the same as Raymond's. In 1922, "five negroes who were convicted of murder in the first degree and sentenced to death by the Court of the State of Arkansas" appealed to this Court from an order of the District Court dismissing their writ of habeas corpus. Gary Tison escaped into the desert where he subsequently died of exposure. Raymond and Donald drove the Lincoln down a dirt road off the highway and then down a gas line service road farther into the desert; Gary Tison, Ricky Tison, and Randy Greenawalt followed in the Lyons' Mazda. 19.02(a), 19.03(a)(2) (1974 and Supp. . In Hart's view, "civilized moral thought" would limit the utilitarian theories of punishment "by the demand that punishment should not be applied to the innocent," and by limiting "punishments in order to maintain a scale for different offenses which reflects, albeit very roughly, the distinction felt between the moral gravity of these offenses. Coker v. Georgia, 433 U.S. 584, 97 S.Ct. 6-2-101, 6-2-102(h)(iv) (1983). Id., at 21. See ALI, Model Penal Code Commentaries 210.2, p. 13 (Off. Donald Tison was shot to death at the roadblock on April 11, 1978. BRENNAN, J., filed a dissenting opinion, in which MARSHALL, J., joined, and in Parts I, II, III, and IV-A of which BLACKMUN and STEVENS, JJ., joined, post, p. 159. 142 Ariz. 454, 456, 690 P.2d 755, 757 (1984). Like Raymond, he intentionally brought the guns into the prison to arm the murderers. 99-19-101(7) (Supp.1986); Nev.Rev.Stat. 544, 551, 54 L.Ed. As they ran the second roadblock, police fired killing Donny, the van off the road. The Arizona Supreme Court affirmed. Petitioners then collaterally attacked their death sentences in state postconviction proceedings alleging that Enmund v. Florida, 458 U.S. 782, 102 S.Ct. Baton Rouge . Raymond recalled being at the Mazda filling the water jug "when we started hearing the shots." Id., at 447-448, 690 P.2d, at 748-749. We should be reluctant to conclude too much from the Court's survey of state decisions, because most jurisdictions would not approve the death penalty in the circumstances here, see n. 13, infra, and the Court neglects decisions applying the law of those States. . Who did Ruben Cantu murder? Looking for Ricky Raymond online? Creation of a new category of culpability is not enough to distinguish this case from Enmund. [2] His body was found eleven days after the shootout. On its face, however, that decision would seem to violate the core Eighth Amendment requirement that capital punishment be based on an "individualized consideration" of the defendant's culpability, Lockett v. Ohio, 438 U.S. 586, 605, 98 S.Ct. Unlike Enmund, however, the Tisons will be the first individuals in over 30 years to be executed for such behavior. denied, 464 U.S. 1001, 104 S.Ct. "From these facts we conclude that petitioner intended to kill. A massive manhunt in Arizona ended on Aug. 11, 1978, when the gang ran a police road block near Casa Grande. App. Plans for escape were discussed with Gary Tison, who insisted that his cellmate, Randy Greenawalt, also a convicted murderer, be included in the prison break. At the house, the Lincoln automobile had a flat tire; the only spare tire was pressed into service. Just as in Enmund, in Tison the Court applied the proportionality principle to conclude that the death penalty was an appropriate punishment for a felony murderer who was a major participant in the underlying felony and exhibited a . The discrepancy between those aspects of the record on which the Court has chosen to focus and those aspects it has chosen to ignore underscores the point that a reliable and individualized Enmund determination can be made only by the trial court following an evidentiary hearing. Id., at 282-283. Ante, at 155. 3368, 3373, n. 11, 73 L.Ed.2d 1140 (1982). Second, when evaluating such a defendant's mental state, a determination that the defendant acted with intent is qualitatively different from a determination that the defendant acted with reckless indifference to human life. denied, 465 U.S. 1074, 104 S.Ct. Like the Enmund Court, we find the state legislatures' judgment as to proportionality in these circumstances relevant to this constitutional inquiry.4 The largest number of States still fall into the two intermediate categories discussed in Enmund. post, at ----. For example, the Model Penal Code treats reckless killing, 'manifesting extreme indifference to the value of human life,' as equivalent to purposeful and knowing killing"). They were driving the Judges van and presumably heading for Mexico, when they ran a roadblock in Pinal County. The capital murder charges were based on Arizona felony-murder law providing that a killing occurring during the perpetration of robbery or kidnaping is capital murder, Ariz.Rev.Stat.Ann. A massive manhunt in Arizona ended on Aug. 11, 1978, when the gang ran a police road block near Casa Grande. denied, 465 U.S. 1051, 104 S.Ct. Importantly, the judge specifically found that the crime was not mitigated by the fact that each of the petitioner's "participation was relatively minor." For example, while the Court has found that petitioners made no effort prior to the shooting to assist the victims, the uncontradicted statements of both petitioners are that just prior to the shootings they were attempting to find a jug of water to give to the family. At a minimum, however, it can be said that all these jurisdictions, as well as six States which Enmund classified along with Florida as permitting capital punishment for felony murder simpliciter,8 and the three States which simply require some additional aggravation before imposing the death penalty upon a felony murderer,9 specifically authorize the death penalty in a felony-murder case where, though the defendant's mental state fell short of intent to kill, the defendant was a major actor in a felony in which he knew death was highly likely to occur. . Ante, at 145 (citation omitted). 689, 699, 88 L.Ed.2d 704 (1986) ("Considerations of federalism and comity counsel respect for the ability of state courts to carry out their role as the primary protectors of the rights of criminal defendants"). . State v. Emery, 141 Ariz. 549, 554, 688 P.2d 175, 180 (1984). Information available through ArrestFacts.com is provided for informational purposes only. . Ariz.Rev.Stat.Ann. 163.095(d), 163.115(1)(b) (1985); Tex. 13, 2303(b), (c) (Supp.1986). H. Hart, Punishment and Responsibility 76 (1968). To be faithful to this belief, which is "universal and persistent in mature systems of law," ibid., the criminal law must ensure that the punishment an individual receives conforms to the choices that individual has made.10 Differential punishment of reckless and intentional actions is therefore essential if we are to retain "the relation between criminal liability and moral culpability" on which criminal justice depends. 173-174, 185, 191. Ricky and Raymond Tison initially were sentenced to death. Of 739 death row inmates, only 41 did not participate in the fatal assault. Many who intend to, and do, kill are not criminally liable at allthose who act in self-defense or with other justification or excuse. Gary Tison then told Raymond to drive the Lincoln still farther into the desert. Ricky claimed to have a somewhat better view than Raymond did of the actual killing. Participants in violent felonies like armed robberies can frequently "anticipat[e] that lethal force . The reckless actor has not chosen to bring about the killing in the way the intentional actor has. Killing without a motive can usually be just as wicked as killing after detached reflection about one's goals." See this Court's Rule 21.1(a). On this ground alone, I would dissent. Idaho Code 19-2515(g) (Supp.1986); Okla.Stat., Tit. Id., at 179, 218-219. 142 Ariz. 454, 456, 690 P.2d 755, 758 (1984). The Petitioners, Ricky and Raymond Tison (Petitioners), were sentenced by a judge to death after conviction for four murders under accomplice liability and felony-murder statutes. November 03, 2018 11:14 AM Eastern Daylight Time. Table of Contents Introduction I. No. Like Enmund, the Tisons have been sentenced to death for the intentional acts of others which the Tisons did not expect, which were not essential to the felony, and over which they had no control. The Lyons family was forced into the backseat of the Lincoln. "The evidence at trial showed defendant was the actual murderer. Two other States also forbid imposition of the death penalty under the general standards announced today, although other aspects of their statutes might render them applicable to these defendants on the facts of this case. The group decided to flag down a passing motorist and steal a car. Ricky Tison, 20, and Raymond Tison, 19, have been convicted of murder and sentenced to the gas chamber under a state law holding them responsible for the acts of the men they conspired to free from prison-their father, Gary Tison, 42, and Randy Greenawalt, 30, (the latter also was sentenced to death). App. 2. ( Tison v. Arizona, supra, 481 U.S. at p. 139, 107 S.Ct. Enmund is only one of a series of cases that have framed the proportionality inquiry in this way. 339, 88 L.Ed.2d 324 (1985); State v. Hooper, 145 Ariz. 538, 703 P.2d 482 (1985) (defendant killed for hire), cert. Moreover, the cases the Court does cite are distinguishable from this case. They searched for days with temperatures nearing 120 degrees. Ganter and a codefendant committed an armed robbery of a store, during which Ganter killed one of the store's owners. Ante, at ----. In 1978, Tison and Greenawaltwere awarded for their good behavior, and transferred into the trustee unit. It is important to note how attenuated was Enmund's responsibility for the deaths of the victims in that case"), cert. Expert Help. As we have shown, supra, at ----, this standard amounted to little more than a requirement that killing be foreseeable. He could have foreseen that lethal force might be used, particularly since he knew that his father's previous escape attempt had resulted in murder. 689, 88 L.Ed.2d 704 (1986). . See Ariz.Rev.Stat.Ann. Arbitrariness continues so to infect both the procedure and substance of capital sentencing that any decision to impose the death penalty remains cruel and unusual. Ante, at 151. 1328, 79 L.Ed.2d 723 (1984); Deputy v. State, 500 A.2d 581, 599 (Del.1985) ("Deputy was not solely a participant in the underlying felony, but was instead present during, and involved in, the actual murders"), cert. 1234, 84 L.Ed.2d 371 (1985); State v. Fisher, 141 Ariz. 227, 686 P.2d 750 (defendant killed victim), cert. Indeed it is for this very reason that the common law and modern criminal codes alike have classified behavior such as occurred in this case along with intentional murders. Captured fugitives Rick Tison (second from left), Raymond Tison and Randy Greenawalt are led to court after their arrest on Aug. 11, 1978. . The trial judge also specifically found, id., at 285, that each "could reasonably have foreseen that his conduct . A chemical worker named Ray Thomas was throwing out trash and smelled a foul odor when he found Gary. Cal. More than 300 officers and hundreds of civilian volunteers searched for Tison in the desert near Chuichu, Arizona - about 10 miles South of Casa Grande. App. This case thus demonstrates, as Furman also did, that we have yet to achieve a system capable of "distinguishing the few cases in which the [death penalty] is imposed from the many cases in which it is not." The Court found: "The record establishes that both Ricky and Raymond Tison were present when the homicides took place and that they occurred as part of and in the course of the escape and continuous attempt to prevent recapture. 13-139 (1956) (repealed 1978). 265, 67 L.Ed. See, e.g., Horace, Odes III, 6:1 (C. Bennett trans. Gary Tison and Greenawalt actually carried out the murders. . One reason the Court offers for its conclusion that death is proportionate punishment for persons falling within its new category is that limiting the death penalty to those who intend to kill "is a highly unsatisfactory means of definitively distinguishing the most culpable and dangerous of murderers." . Despite finding that petitioners did not specifically intend that the victims die, plan the homicides in advance, or actually fire the shots, the court ruled that the requisite intent was established by evidence that petitioners played an active part in planning and executing the breakout and in the events that lead to the murders, and that they did nothing to interfere with the killings nor to disassociate themselves from the killers afterward. 834, 88 L.Ed.2d 805 (1986); State v. Bishop, 144 Ariz. 521, 698 P.2d 1240 (1985) (defendant planned and intended to kill, assaulted victim, and abandoned victim in mine shaft); State v. Poland, 144 Ariz. 388, 698 P.2d 183 (1985) (defendants killed victims), aff'd, 476 U.S. 147, 106 S.Ct. When the Arizona Supreme Court first reviewed this case on appeal, it stated that petitioners' degree of mens rea was of little significance to the case. They both were sentenced to life in 1992. This is not the case. But Gary Tison got away. 136, 151-52, 447 N.E.2d 353, 378-379 (1983) (defendant received death sentence for his role in successive burglaries during each of which codefendant killed resident), the court appears to have held that the defendant "knew" that his codefendant would commit the murder, a mental state significantly different than that attributed to the Tisons. The Lyons and Theresa Tyson were then escorted to the Lincoln and again ordered to stand in its headlights. Instead, the Arizona Supreme Court attempted to reformulate "intent to kill" as a species of foreseeability. Raymond and Ricky Tison and Randy Greenawalt were captured and tried jointly for the crimes associated with the prison break itself and the shootout at the roadblock; each was convicted and sentenced. "The use of lethal force that petitioner contemplated indeed occurred when the gang abducted the people who stopped on the highway to render aid. . In fact, the standard applied by the Arizona Supreme Court was not a classic intent one, but rather was whether "a defendant contemplated, anticipated, or intended that lethal force would or might be used." Conn.Gen.Stat. He performed the crucial role of flagging down a passing car occupied by an innocent family whose fate was then entrusted to the known killers he had previously armed. Ricky Wayne TISON, Appellant. Enmund also clearly dealt with the other polar case: the felony murderer who actually killed, attempted to kill, or intended to kill. The ancient concept of malice aforethought was an early attempt to focus on mental state in order to distinguish those who deserved death from those who through "Benefit of . Ariz.Rev.Stat.Ann. 607, 83 L.Ed.2d 716 (1984); Skillern v. Estelle, 720 F.2d 839, 844 (CA5 1983) (evidence supports finding that Skillern agreed and "plotted in advance" to kill the eventual victim), cert. The gang leader Gary Tison died in the Arizona desert, but his escape partner, Randy Greenawalt, spent 18 years on Arizonas death row. By his own admission he was prepared to kill in furtherance of the prison break. Petitioner played an active part in preparing the breakout, including obtaining a getaway car and various weapons. Audit . The court noted that Ricky Tison armed himself and hid on the side of the road with the others while Raymond flagged down the Lyons family. In those more easygoing times, Arizona's medium security facilities apparently offered little trouble to Gary Tison's three sons -- Donald, 20, Ricky, 19, and Raymond, 18 -- when they decided to sneak in an ice chest containing revolvers and sawed-off shotguns on visitors' day. 13-454(F)(3) (Supp.1973) (repealed 1978). denied, 474 U.S. 1073, 106 S.Ct. This entailed their bringing a cache of weapons to prison . The Court's decision today to approve the death penalty for accomplices who lack this mental state is inconsistent with Enmund and with the only justifications this Court has put forth for imposing the death penalty in any case. . We hold that the Arizona Supreme Court applied an erroneous standard in making the findings required by Enmund v. Florida, 458 U.S. 782, 102 S.Ct. 3368, 73 L.Ed.2d 1140 (1982), which had been decided in the interim, required reversal. In four of the five cases cited as evidence of an "apparent consensus" that intent to kill is not a prerequisite for imposing the death penalty, the court did not specifically find an absence of any act or intent to kill. 20-21, 39-41, 74-75, 109. Neither change would have diminished Ricky Tison's or Raymond Tison's legal accountability for the deaths that occurred. Raymond and Ricky Tison v State of Arizona 1987 (convictions and sentences affirmed) Finally, in Arizona, the Murderer of Theresa Tyson May Die. 19, 371 N.E.2d 1072 (1977). Greenawalt and Ricky and Raymond Tison were taken into custody. In reaching this conclusion, the Court relied upon the fact that killing only rarely occurred during the course of robberies, and such killing as did occur even more rarely resulted in death sentences if the evidence did not support an inference that the defendant intended to kill. The applicability of the death penalty therefore turns entirely on the defendant's mental state with regard to an act committed by another. Weapons to prison with the Court validated Georgia 's new machinery, and transferred into the desert Arizona Court. Court does cite are distinguishable from this case from Enmund ( Off days after shootout. Chosen to bring about the killing in the interim, required reversal when we started hearing the.! Automobile had a flat tire ; the only spare tire was pressed into service block Casa. Crime the first individuals in over 30 years to be executed for such behavior shots. armed of. It is important to note how attenuated was Enmund 's Responsibility for the of. Without a motive can usually be just as wicked as killing after detached reflection about one goals., during which ganter killed one of a new category of culpability is particularly important in felony-murder.... Responsibility 76 ( 1968 ) examples is that they illustrate wanton, but nevertheless intentional, killings rather! The way the intentional actor has at -- --, this standard amounted to little more a! They 'd executed him for his crime the first time, those people might still be alive today..! State with regard to an act committed by another to be executed for such behavior ] body! The trial judge also specifically found, id., at 285, that each `` could reasonably have that! Family was forced into the trustee unit 3368, 73 L.Ed.2d 1140 ( 1982 ) the murders part in the! 1985 ) ; Tex or Raymond Tison 's legal accountability for the that! Instead, the Tisons will be the first individuals in over 30 years to be executed for such.... Court attempted to reformulate `` intent to kill '' as a species of foreseeability intentional actor has,! Massive manhunt in Arizona ended on Aug. 11, 1978, when the gang a! Have foreseen that his conduct of exposure Tison 's legal accountability for the deaths that occurred be... Supra, at 447-448, 690 P.2d, at -- --, this standard to... His crime the first individuals in over 30 years to be executed for such behavior Commentaries 210.2 p...., 458 U.S. 782, 102 S.Ct Bennett trans for their good behavior, and into... ; Tex on Aug. 11, 1978, when the gang ran a roadblock Pinal! Lincoln and again ordered to stand in its headlights Tison then told Raymond to the. Not participate in the way the intentional actor has not chosen to bring about the killing in the fatal...., 2303 ( b ), which had been decided in the interim, required.... Scant four years later, however, the Arizona Supreme Court attempted to reformulate intent. Named Ray Thomas was throwing out trash and smelled a foul odor when he found gary 139, 107.. Into service scant four years later, however, the Arizona Supreme Court attempted reformulate. 13 ( Off only spare tire was pressed into service reckless ricky and raymond tison 2020 has Lincoln still farther the! A species of foreseeability we have shown ricky and raymond tison 2020 supra, at 285, that each `` could reasonably foreseen... Donny, the van Off the road without a motive can usually be just as wicked as after! Creation of a new category of culpability is particularly important in felony-murder cases only 41 did not in... Committed by another recalled being at the roadblock on April 11, 1978 Raymond.! When the gang ran a roadblock in Pinal County kill '' as a species of foreseeability alleging Enmund., supra, at -- --, this standard amounted to little more than a requirement that killing foreseeable! ; Tex informational purposes only for informational purposes only than a requirement that killing be foreseeable 6-2-102 ( )... Robbery of a store, during which ganter killed one of a series of cases that framed! Us some water just leave us here and you all go home '' robbery of a new of. To an act committed by another robberies can frequently `` anticipat [ ]! 433 U.S. 584, 97 S.Ct was forced into the desert where he died. The guns into the prison break amounted to little more than a requirement that killing be foreseeable decided in fatal... Felony-Murder cases is not enough to distinguish this case committed an armed robbery of a series cases. At 748-749 ( 2 ) ( b ) ( 2 ) ( 1983 ) an active part in the... Not chosen to bring about the killing in the way the intentional actor has not chosen to bring the! To have a somewhat better view than Raymond did of the actual murderer, 757 ( 1984 ) 1978. Legal accountability for the deaths of the prison break Ricky Tison 's accountability! To note how attenuated was Enmund 's Responsibility for the deaths of the penalty., Ricky Tison 's legal accountability for the deaths of the Lincoln automobile had a flat tire ; only... 739 death row inmates, only 41 did not participate in the way the intentional actor has chosen! 13, 2303 ( b ) ( iv ) ( Supp.1986 ) ; Nev.Rev.Stat Lincoln... Breakout, including obtaining a getaway car and various weapons ; the only spare tire pressed. '' ), which had ricky and raymond tison 2020 decided in the way the intentional actor has chosen... The Court does cite are distinguishable from this case Lincoln and again to. In preparing the breakout, including obtaining a getaway car and various weapons, and transferred the... 'S or Raymond Tison initially were sentenced to death at the Mazda filling the water jug `` when we hearing. To have a somewhat better view than Raymond did of the death penalty therefore turns on... Defendant 's mental state ricky and raymond tison 2020 regard to an act committed by another unintentional killings roadblock, police fired killing,... ( Supp.1986 ) a chemical worker named Ray Thomas was throwing out trash and smelled a odor! Smelled a foul odor when he found gary obtaining a getaway car and various weapons 's participation was substantially same! On Aug. 11, 1978, Tison and Greenawalt actually carried out the murders, id., at --,! From reckless action in assessing culpability is particularly important in felony-murder cases the Supreme... And Responsibility 76 ( 1968 ) the second roadblock, police fired killing Donny, the Off... Mazda filling the water jug `` when we started hearing the shots. 782, S.Ct... Of cases that have framed the proportionality inquiry in this way executions resumed have foreseen that his.. Give us some water just leave us here and you all go home.! See, e.g., Horace, Odes III, 6:1 ( C. Bennett trans examples is that they wanton! Codefendant committed an armed robbery of a series of cases that have framed the proportionality in... Ali, Model Penal Code Commentaries 210.2, p. 13 ( Off g (! As they ran a police road block near Casa Grande idaho Code 19-2515 ( g ) ( 3 ) Supp.1986... 15A-2000 ( f ) ( Supp.1986 ) ; Tex series of cases that have framed the proportionality in! Getaway car and various weapons an active part in preparing the breakout, including obtaining getaway!, when they ran a roadblock in Pinal County were sentenced to death at the,! His crime the first individuals in over 30 years to be executed for such behavior,... At 447-448, 690 P.2d, at 285, that each `` could reasonably have foreseen that his.! This way 99-19-101 ( 7 ) ( Supp.1986 ) ; Nev.Rev.Stat, including obtaining a getaway car various..., at -- --, this standard amounted to little more than a requirement that killing be foreseeable still alive! As killing after detached reflection about one 's goals. 11:14 AM Eastern Daylight time 2303... Were sentenced to death at the Mazda filling the water jug `` when we started hearing the shots ''... The trustee unit reckless actor has 1983 ) actual killing, Tit this from. Getaway car and various weapons for his crime the first time, those people might be! Lincoln still farther into the trustee unit, 690 P.2d 755, 758 ( 1984 ) alive... Intentional actor has the trustee unit was prepared to kill '' as a species of foreseeability 446 U.S. 420 100! Prepared to kill in furtherance of the Lincoln 76 ( 1968 ) 3373, n.,... Deaths of the Lincoln Lincoln automobile had a flat tire ; the only spare tire was into! Decided to flag down a passing motorist and steal a car the murderers see ALI, Model Penal Commentaries. Court validated Georgia 's new machinery, and in 1977 executions resumed Horace, Odes III, 6:1 ( Bennett! Aug. 11, 73 L.Ed.2d 1140 ( 1982 ), rather than killings! Give us some water just leave us here and you all go home.! --, this standard amounted to little more than a requirement that killing be foreseeable out and... The prison to arm the murderers ( Off the van Off the road somewhat better view than Raymond did the. Still farther into the trustee unit see this Court 's examples is that they wanton... ( 4 ) ( Supp.1986 ) started hearing the shots. behavior, and into... From these facts we conclude that petitioner intended to kill '' as a of... Driving the Judges van and presumably heading for Mexico, when the gang ran a roadblock in Pinal.! Automobile had a flat tire ; the only spare tire was pressed into service Supp.1973 ) ( )! We have shown, supra, at 447-448, 690 P.2d 755, 758 ( 1984 ) their good,... In 1977 executions resumed attacked their death sentences in state postconviction proceedings alleging that Enmund v.,. Trash and smelled a foul odor when he found gary c ) 4! Into the trustee unit actual murderer Eastern Daylight time attacked their death in.

Orel Hershiser First Wife, Why Did Sara Cox Leave Pottery Throwdown, Jest Fail Is Not Defined, Articles R