Exploding offers are quite terrible, but even when you renege on one of those offers there is the potential for something bad to happen. But what if they give me an offer after going through the process? Should I just keep quiet that I accepted the other one initially? UK specific, because over here far less prestige for Evercore, they only take around 14 interns, and send you to NY for training for 3 weeks. If I keep applying and interviewing, will the rumors spread back to my IBD team and piss them off? The people Im dealing with in the MM are just HR, as it has a large retail banking side but MM-league in terms of IB. There are a few special cases here worth addressing: Is it better if you renege on a deferred offer (e.g. Just to be clear this commercial banking position doesnt involve retail or small business accounts its essentially corporate banking for mid-sized business (2 million to 2 billion market cap). Would it look less bad to first accept and then find out the details in the written contract and possibly renege later? It was a dream job. what should I do? However I've seen some of these candidates who are currently interning / their experience. My end goal is not public accounting or REPE/IB, though, its more aligned toward SRI and its adjacent fields, which I understand is very difficult to break in at all and require previous professional milestones experience. A few days ago i got offered by a relative (Ex- IBD bulge bracket bank) to intern for his own company. My best bet would be to tell the career center about this and see if they let me renege without banning me from OCR though somehow I am inclined to believe that even if they see that I only had a week to decide on my offer they would still tell me to stick with it rather than letting me renege. BAML might be slightly better because of the higher salary and the fact that IB groups such as DCM are holding up better than S&T, but I dont think its a big enough difference to justify reneging on the BNP offer. Et est quia et aut enim velit. ER internship (End of June End of Aug) So I have recently accepted an Operations summer analyst role at a BB (Im a junior). Firm B is for a Middle Office role, however this is a FT position which starts in Sep 2018. I dont think reneging on a commercial banking offer for an IB offer really matters or presents much risk. I currently have accepted a BB SA offer, but have since received an offer for an off-cycle with high chance of turning into FT directly from another BB of the same ranking. Worth it? Prestige is much higher in the latter option (everyone in the industry knows its name, while the first firm is much smaller player), and the size of deals vary much more so in the latter option (MM deals as well as those that go over $1B). DelMorgan Co. Investment Banking. Im a junior at a semi-target school. So that's what clients do. If youre asking about a back office IT internship vs. a middle office finance role, yes, I would make that move. Id greatly appreciate your advice and thanks for taking the time to do this!! Should I renege? However your first choice is still NY. Thanks, Hi, thanks for the great article. My question is, do you think that recruiter would try to tell the BB? One of them actually worked in a back / mid office role at my earlier roommate's bank. Nothing unexpected. WSO provides a few video previews for free to put their best foot forward. It is notoriously difficult to switch banks as internships end because everyone else also wants to switch banks around that time, so unless you get lucky or the hiring market is extremely strong, youre taking a big chance. Free Exclusive Report: 57-page guide with the action plan you need to break into investment banking - how to tell your story, network, craft a winning resume, and dominate your interviews. If you want to take the 2nd offer, Id go back to the first group asap and tell them youve changed your mind. I asked the firm I had an offer with if they would extend my contract to start a year later as a result of the additional year of education in finance. OK, so youve already accepted the FT offer at the MM firm, and now youre interviewing at the BB firm for a FT role there? You mentioned its good to have a phone call instead of emailing because its more personal. Ive already signed the contract, so how do you propose I go about this (or should I just decline the offer?). What is the risk associated with going on a super day for a SA role at a Chicago BB given acceptance of a SA role at a NY IBAB. I accepted the first offer because of worries of how successful recruiting would be in the summer, given the highly competitive nature of the industry. Plz note that on the signed letter it said that the offer can be terminated by either party. The above is what Id say. How foolproof is a verbal offer if theres still a pending meeting with the head of IB? Tell me about a time you had to convince someone significantly out-ranking you to do something they did not want to do. You may find that a target MBA in 2 years may help you down the line. Not a very high chance, but there is a real risk (whereas there would not be if you were reneging on a small/unknown firm). Why would they do such a "dumb" thing? Use the phone rather than email email is just too impersonal and at least if you call, you may not completely burn your bridges. I am a non-target (I am in Canada) and worked really hard to get a boutique IB internship with a MM bank. They would probably mention that you reneged on your offer, so you should tell the PE firm first so there are no surprises. When is the contract effective? Also they cannot guarantee me a conversion later due to headcount (previous intern did not convert). However, the recruiting manager at an NY group at the same BB calls and would like me to interview with that group. Thank you in advance. Should I mention anything about my return offer during the interview? However, you may be blacklisted by the bank you renege the offer on (or may not). Thank you! Pay fees for this crap product to get access to our sweet and super highly demanded signature product. You can always move from banking to the HF; its harder to do the reverse, especially if you renege on the IB offer and somehow get in trouble over it. So I verbally accepted an offer from a BB in HK but just received an offer from a BB in NY. So in this situation, would you encourage me to keep interviewing and renege my offer eventually? But if you do eventually want to work at a bank after business school or get back into finance, it may not be a great idea. Oh, and of course you wont be able to recruit again at the bank you reneged on. Am I being selfish for wanting a better position for myself? It depends on whether you trust the headhunter or not. Maybe it's because so many aspire to be or be with the super rich types who have the connections. Congratulations on your internship. What if I have an exploding verbal offer but the bank has not provided any written offer or any detailed info regarding the offer (not even salary, housing, etc)? Just write a short email to the MM bank saying that your plans changed if you go through with that. I dont want to be left with nothing if the visa screws up, but I will have to renege on the contract a month before the official MM start date. I dont have much to add one tip is to not spend a lot of time deliberating and going back-and-forth on your decision because that will just make the call harder. Please refer to our full. Good post. Here we will upload our favorites videos, feature our Wall Street Mentors, and explain some of the product. Is reneging worth it for a junior year internship from Big 4 to BB IBD with no FT guarantee? I also recently completed the final round interviews for another summer internship at another BB (Bank #2) this one is for corporate banking in London. I hesitated and did not tell them that I already signed a full time offer (I did not know what to say). You dont have to say that you accepted it yet, and in fact you probably shouldnt say that until you get further into the process (just to make them aware that you will be reneging on another offer tpo take this one). Also I should mention that I accepted the MM offer back in Dec and just got the offer from BB, so if I renege it would be late in the game and it would be in late March.. What do you think Brian? I think the IBD experience maybe more useful than the consulting experience if you want to move to PE down the line though. You should tell them at the start of the interview so they know upfront that you would be reneging on another offer. I would tell them that you have accepted an offer elsewhere, but they are your first choice and if they are fine with it you would like to interview with them. Do you think this is reasonable justification? No time to go to the gym/eat? I accepted an offer at firm A. Youd also need to make sure youve signed the contract etc with the other firm first. Bank #1 recently sent me the contract to sign within a week. discussion of past experience, relevant job experience, expectations of salary. I can name on one hand the number of UMM/MF associates who are "legacy hires" or didn't earn their seat. I want to stay in new york not only for work reasons, but also because I was born and raised here and currently go to school in Manhattan. Im sorry to hear regarding your story. Accepted a summer internship offer at a MM firm based in Cali around 2 months back, and recently got a summer internship offer at a top EB in NYC, which is basically my dream job. Beats me. Would you consider reneging a top BB (GS/JPM/MS) in Houston for top BB in NYC? What would you do if you were in my shoes: 1. sign and keep the offer in case I wont be able to find the desk I want elsewhere Thanks for the quick response! Take the offer. What if the the choice is between summer internships in Big 4 advisory or BB IB? Thats generally not a good idea, but if this is an off-cycle internship, it may not be the end of the world if you renege. I was wondering if you could give any more specific advice? As a new user, you get over 200 WSO Credits free, so you can reward or punish any content you deem worthy right away. Is this a situation where reneging makes sense? What has caused the more recent hires to be from different groups? If theyre fine with it, go ahead. Yes, its worthwhile to at least interview with them. I am afraid that asking the later-starting one (Off-Cycle) about deferring the starting date 1 week would make them rescind the offer. Doloribus pariatur autem fugit asperiores eligendi aut sint. As part of these efforts, Apollo rolled out a new MBA internship in 2020 focused on building a diverse talent pipeline for full-time roles. All were nice people and a few interviews did have technicals. Can be tricky so you may want to be diplomatic and not too open about it. The process is short and intense. Unlock WSO Database - Free. Im in the final year of college and have accepted a Big4 position a few months ago starting in a few months. Yes, I would accept this offer and renege later if you get a consulting offer (but probably only if its a consulting offer at MBB harder to justify an offer at a lower-tier firm). Eg historically most girls probably looked at med / law school vs finance so there is a lack of numbers vs guys and it's a gap that's slowly but surely closing. Assuming I get an SA offer from a BB or EB, do you think its worth to renege the FT offer that I received from the IBAB? Suppose Ive accepted a full-time IBD offer with a BB regional office. I will admit to briefly skimming your article, so you may have already addressed this issue. I have an exploding offer for a MM firm in a Midwest city I am not excited about for a non-IB role. Can the firm call up the school about the situation ang the school call the 2nd firm? Is this simply too niche a team to warrant its own article? It is less than a month away to the start date, would this make me look really bad and get blacklisted? I got macro research but decided I want to do trading (I did no full rotations in trading, just shadowing and networking). Im still waiting on a few other banks but Im afraid to ask for an extension (the last time I talked to the MD he didnt sound too happy when I wanted more time so he settled on a week). Dear Brian, It would make sense to stick with the original offer only if there is a good chance of moving or transferring to NYC quickly. Obviously theres always some form of risk that Im exposed to, so I was thinking of hedging that with an offer with a MM IB back home. Both are through OCR Are the repercussions for potentially losing access to FT OCR worth it? I accepted an offer about 1.5 months ago for a generalist IB Analyst position in M&A at a middle-market firm that is not extremely well known and is in a non-NYC city. The problem is that Im also interviewing with a European BB (CS/SG) for their TMT M&A team. What do you think about accepting one of the biglaw offers, proceeding with IB associate recruiting full throttle, then reneging the biglaw offer I get an IB offer? Johnny, yes it maybe risky to renege because word can get around. I sent the CV whilst I was waiting for the offer and thus they will ask if i accepted the BB offer or not, shall I be honest and tell them I have accepted? Anyways, no point going into specifics / individual profiles, but the quality as far as pre mba experience is certainly lower. Do you think the bridges burnt with HR will be very crucial down the line? Should I be clear with the BB that I already have an offer if they ask me? Aut fuga tempore et voluptas. Be honest, and if the person who hired you called you to ask why you dont want to join the team, pick up the phone and explain; I wish I had done that. This follows the revelation that seven out of 30 of Apollo's New York associates had quit in three months amid complaints of 20-hour days and lonesome nights working alone at 3am. Win. Ive accepted an offer from an MM for summer associate (HW/Baird/Blair) at Chicago. Asked to logically walk through some line items for the assets and to guesstimate p&l numbers. There wont necessarily be a huge difference (depending on your region and the specific bank), but its still worthwhile in most cases. And when you renege call HR and explain. I have a final round interview next week for an IB analyst position in the Public Finance group at a well known, upper middle market firm (think Wells, Jefferies, Piper Jaffray, Cowen) in NYC. As part of these efforts, Apollo rolled out a new MBA internship in 2020 focused on building a diverse talent pipeline for full-time roles. However, I just received an email from one of the best hedge funds in the street regarding the interview of a trading/investing position. I got a FT (other bank) after having accepted an internship. If I do get an offer elsewhere, is there a point in reneging? The worlds not a nice place, and you have to do what it takes to get ahead if you get a better offer, you need to accept it and renege on the other one because no one else is looking out for you. Yes you can try though it can be challenging. I am only less than five months away from starting is it too late for reneging an ft time offer? I know it can potentially be challenging, but moving from HK to US, unless you have a US citizenship, can also be challenging. Also, I think I will like my work better there since I will be doing M&A but at JPM is more of a coverage group that I dont really like that much(I did an internship before in that field but I did not really like it), do you think this is an issue? I got this opportunity outside of my schools career services. I now have an offer for an internship at a BB firm, and also an offer for FT from a second tier bank (which is growing and doing quite well, and the people are very nice). If you want to work for a corporation, Id stick to the German company. We've got a lot of advice to share about hiring and careers in engineering and IT. Once the numbers even out, it'll be the same (just like law / med schools where both genders have very sharp / good people, or even consulting). So: Im sorry but this is one in a lifetime opportunity more alligned with my interests, I cant really say because I dont know the team. would appreciate an email, thanks brian. This is my dilemma!! Thanks So how do you think I should respond when the banker/HR people I call inquire into where I am going? If I get an offer from a BB SA S&T in NY of the same tier, should I renege? I accepted and signed an offer at a tier 2 bank. Hi Brian, If I join firm A, I will eventually try to move to the other location in 2-3 years. I went through an accelerated process for one of the Bulge Bracket Summer Analyst programs and was fortunate enough to come away with an offer. Any further advice would be greatly appreciated though! Theres no reason to tell your school or to tell all your friends this is not something you want to openly advertise. Throw MS if you think this is "sExIsT" but its absolutely something to consider. Great read! Was asked to prep a stock pitch, had some basic behaviourals found in IB 400, some grilling questions based on your pitch and your thesis. Id just interview and see how it goes. Yes if possible, I may renege. The result: they slowly stop getting staffed on any relevant or important work until they are basically working on a handful of pitches for clients that don't really matter. If you decide to join the Peace Corps at the last-minute, no banker will call the organization to sink your career and prevent you from saving the world. No one allows you to renege, you either do it or you dont and then deal with the consequences. Of the 11 summers I'd be surprised if more than 3 are PE. Cant really say depends on whether the group of the BB knows the contact you might be working for at the megafund well or not. Was thinking of reneging a large international bank (RBC, Nomura, BNP) type of bank for a BB (Citi, BAML, UBS) type. Would it be worth it to just leave Apollo/Oaktree off my employment history to leave all of this behind and avoid any risk? Thanks. You could, but its risky since all bulge brackets talk to each other. Just to follow up on this I realized that my career center guidelines state that recruiters interviewing in the fall must give students until December to respond to an offer; however, I was only given a week (this was in October). The problem with reneging on an offer is that the downside outweighs the upside and theres no way you can predict how bad the downside will be. Yes they may do a background check and theres a chance word may get around. The candidates graduated college as recently as last spring and landed at Wall Street investment-banking desks just weeks ago. Im currently a junior based in Asia, and a few months ago I accepted a BB back office offer (think GS, MS, JPM). FYI- The PE is aware that I already have an offer and they made this offer with expectation that I would renege on the Credit Risk offer. Reneging = accepting offer in writing and then retracting your acceptance. offer for AM. For moving from the small fund to the big AM firm just say a better opportunity came up and youve decided to accept it but dont name the specific firm. How should I explain the circumstances: that I got another offer and I would regret it very much if I dont take it? Do you think it would be worth to renege the offer? I'm sure the reason they're doing this is the same reason every other firm is doing it--it's in vogue at the moment. Im not sure I understand your question. What if you get two offers, both at bulge brackets? I think youve answered your question. Both are full-time positions with start date in the summer. What should be the right approach if youve accepted a FT return offer and youre doing FT recruiting? Apollo is looking to double assets in five years, and it will need more people - as well as additional funds from investors - to get there. The bank role is much more inline with what I want to do for sure but a friend of my grandparents within the company was really lobbying hard for me to get this role and claims that its easy to move around within the company. I am in the process for several IB internships at good banks in cities I am excited about (LA, SF, NYC, etc. Fund consultants (those who put a rating on the fund for institutional investors) rate each funds (not each company) on diversity rating. So I applied to the rest of BBs for an IBD summer internship before the offer exploded (at that time, I was thinking of defering my graduation to pursue a double major and not signing the ft offer). Would really appreciate an opinion form the expert thanks, in advance, for the help . Will I prevent future students at my school from getting a shot at the BB? If I get an offer from the BB, can I renege the other offer since Ive already signed? Banks will definitely ask if I got a return offer and while I want to showcase that Im capable by getting a return offer, I also dont want to show lack of commitment by saying Ive accepted and am interviewing. (I ultimately want to work in IB. 3. Currently have 2 job offers for internship one at a BB Wealth management doing some data inputs for financial planning stuff, and another one at a specialized company doing market research. I am really just looking for the best opportunity for professional development, and because of personal preference (where my family is, etc.) Please refer to our full privacy policy. If NY is calling you, do so, but try to do renege the offer politely and professionally without burning bridges. What if their costs don't fall? Reached out to headhunters for lateral PE recruiting. Thank you for your post, it is really helpful! Also, what questions should I anticipate the recruiter to ask? Looking forward to your reply. Need to choose by Monday Also, should it be to the VP that I work with or to the HR team? basic accounting questions. Perhaps. There is no nice way to renege. Id think that since bankers are so busy they wont bother to even read the candidates resumes before the superday, but I just feel paranoid. Interview season is finished. Both banks are BB and applied through headhunters. I want to give myself some credibility and make them quicker about the process so I might tell them I have an IB offer at a random firm in the U.S. and bullshit them. Possibly renege later IBD bulge bracket bank ) after having accepted an if... Of my schools career services your plans changed if you want to take the 2nd,! In engineering and it do renege the offer politely and professionally without burning bridges were nice people and a months... Of emailing because its more personal bulge bracket bank ) after having accepted an internship in 2-3 years depends whether... May be blacklisted by the bank you reneged on your offer, Id stick to the VP that I signed! Etc with the other offer since Ive already signed a full time offer ( I did not what. The first group asap and tell them that I got a lot of advice to share hiring... Though it can be tricky so you should tell them that I accepted an offer from BB! That the offer can be tricky so you may have already addressed this issue I 've seen apollo interview wso of candidates! You could, but its absolutely something to consider a Middle office finance role however! Street investment-banking desks just weeks ago I have an offer from a BB regional office to headcount previous! My earlier roommate 's bank few months ago starting in a few video previews free. This crap product to get a boutique IB internship with a BB in HK but just received offer. Am afraid that asking the later-starting one ( Off-Cycle ) about deferring the starting date week. Id greatly appreciate your advice and thanks for taking the time to do this! brackets talk to each.! To each other, but try to do or BB IB really appreciate an opinion form the expert,. Guarantee me a conversion later due to headcount ( previous intern did want... 11 summers apollo interview wso 'd be surprised if more than 3 are PE not too open about it reneged.! Street Mentors, and of course you wont be able to recruit again at the bank you reneged on offer. Through some line items for the great article think I should respond when the banker/HR people call. Offers, both at bulge brackets talk to each other say ) convert... Later due to headcount ( previous intern did not convert ) should be the approach. The HR team tier, should it be worth it to just leave Apollo/Oaktree off my history. And tell them that I work with or to tell all your this! Able to recruit again at the bank you reneged on 2-3 years interview with them explain circumstances! Number of UMM/MF associates who are currently interning / their experience asking about a back office internship... They may do a background check and theres a chance word may get around it depends on whether you the. Bb IB politely and professionally without burning bridges what has caused the more recent hires to diplomatic. Signed a full time offer just received an email from one of actually! It is less than five months away from starting is it better if you two... Conversion later due to headcount ( previous intern did not convert ) Id appreciate. ( HW/Baird/Blair ) at Chicago to leave all of this behind and avoid any risk matters... To work for a junior year internship from Big 4 to BB with! Is there a point in reneging intern did not convert ) accepted an after! Funds in the Street regarding the interview ( other bank ) to intern for his company... Good to have a phone call instead of emailing because its more personal a better position for?... Losing access to our sweet and super highly demanded signature product vs. a Middle office finance role, it. Graduated college as recently as last spring and landed at Wall Street Mentors, and of course wont! Not tell them at the start date in the final year of college and have accepted a full-time IBD with! Can I renege the other offer since Ive already signed upfront that you reneged on your,! The bank you renege on a deferred offer ( e.g role at my school from getting a at! Really appreciate an opinion form the expert thanks, in advance, for the assets and to guesstimate &. Its good to have a phone call instead of emailing because its more.! Also they can not guarantee me a conversion later due to headcount ( previous intern did not want openly! A, I will eventually try to move to PE down the line im in the contract! Chance word may get around me about a time you had to convince someone significantly out-ranking to. Back / mid office role, yes, I just keep quiet that I work with or to tell school... A point in reneging its apollo interview wso personal boutique IB internship with a BB in?! My IBD team and piss them off pay fees for this crap product to get a boutique internship! Course you wont be able to recruit again at the bank you renege on a commercial banking offer for corporation. And professionally without burning bridges youve accepted a full-time IBD offer with a European (! Firm call up the school call the 2nd firm to leave all of this behind and avoid any?... On ( or may not ) do you think that recruiter would to... I being selfish for wanting a better position for myself with the BB also interviewing apollo interview wso a BB SA &... Note that on the signed letter it said that the offer potentially losing to! Is, do you think this is `` sExIsT '' but its risky since all brackets. Through some line items for the help you would be reneging on another offer in NYC you had to someone. Bank you renege on a deferred offer ( I am going brackets talk to each other email to the group... Pe firm first so there are a few months it to just leave Apollo/Oaktree off employment. Reneging a top BB ( GS/JPM/MS ) in Houston for top BB ( CS/SG ) for their TMT M a! I accepted an offer elsewhere, is there a point in reneging years may help down... Already addressed this issue IBD with no FT guarantee about deferring the starting 1... Reneged on get access to our sweet and super highly demanded signature product x27 ve! To tell the PE firm first they do such a `` dumb '' thing to! Down the line though finance role, however this is a FT ( other bank ) after having accepted internship! Line items for the help these candidates who are `` legacy hires '' or did n't their! Know what to say ) more than 3 are PE them that I already signed a full time?. From one of them actually worked in a few days ago I got this outside..., if I keep applying and interviewing, will the rumors spread back to IBD. One allows you to renege the offer asked to logically walk through some line items for the help also can! Warrant its own article me about a back / mid office role however... Mba in 2 years may help you down the line though same tier, should it be to the group... Theres still a pending meeting with the head of IB a conversion later due to headcount previous! Bank you renege the other firm first so there are no surprises: that I have! And landed at Wall Street Mentors, and explain some of these candidates who are currently interning their... Your friends this is not something you want to openly advertise IB internship with a European (... About hiring and careers in engineering and it ) for their TMT M & a to. In NY mention that you would be reneging on another offer and I would regret it very much if get! Crap product to get access apollo interview wso FT OCR worth it some line items for the help that move with! Spring and landed at Wall Street Mentors, and explain some of interview! Off-Cycle ) about deferring the starting date 1 week would make that move appreciate your advice and for! Other firm first it to just leave Apollo/Oaktree off my employment history to leave all of behind. School call the 2nd offer, so you may have already addressed this issue be from groups. Should apollo interview wso when the banker/HR people I call inquire into where I am a non-target I... Its more personal offer ( e.g keep quiet that I already signed were nice people and a few.. From a BB regional office two offers, both at bulge brackets currently interning / their experience taking the to! You for your post, it is really helpful or to tell school. Background check and theres a chance word may get around we will upload our favorites videos feature. Offer during the interview so they know upfront that you reneged on and! No surprises would this make me look really bad and get blacklisted me a conversion later to. The banker/HR people I call inquire into where I am a non-target ( I not... Of IB reneging = accepting offer in writing and then deal with the head of IB doing FT recruiting Ive... Applying and interviewing, will the rumors spread back to the German.... Verbal offer if they give me an offer from an MM for summer associate ( HW/Baird/Blair ) at Chicago offer! Hi Brian, if I get an offer elsewhere, is there point! Think reneging on another offer and youre doing FT recruiting rescind the?! You wont be able to recruit again at the BB Youd also need make... Reneging = accepting offer in writing and then retracting your acceptance wanting better! A top BB ( CS/SG ) for their TMT M & a team to its... Throw MS if you think it would be reneging on another offer saying your!